Card Set Information
Elements of defense to manslaughter
-State of passion and suddeness
Modern trend for evaluating Adequate Provacation
- Issue now left to jury to decide whether provocation would render ordinary person liable to act rashly.
-consider defendants characteristics in measuring gravity of the provocation but not to measure level of self control to be expected.
State of passion and suddeness
Applies to adequate provocation
-defendant must kill while in state of passion
-must not have had reasonable opportunity to cool off
Applies to adequate provocation
-casual link between provocation, passion, death must be proved
Define: voluntary manslaughter
as unlawful killing not from malice bt from sudden passion induced by reasonable provocation, sudden combat, or excessive force in self defense.
- mitigate murder to voluntary manslaughter
self defense elements
- If the person is not the agresser
-She reasonbly believes such force is necessary to repel the imminent use of unlawful deadly force by another person.
•Defendant can rais self defense and imperfect self defense at same time
What degree of murder would depraved heart murder qualify as...
How does the MPC qualify Depraved Heart Murder
•reckless murder committed under circumstances manifesting extreme indifference to the value of human life
Common law felony murder rule
A person is guilty of murder is shekills another even accidentally during commission or attempted commission
What are the two ways to look at inherently dangerous felony limitation?
-Look at the definition of the felony in the penal code.
-Look at the circumstances of a case. Facts
MPC felony murder rule (210.2)
Under the MPC` a reckless killing is:
A person who kills another person in criminally negligent manner
(subjective standard-- Realized the risk)
under the mpc manslaughter can happen in 2 ways
1) homicide commited recklessly = manslaughter
Common law definition of voluntary act
Definition of willed
a willed muscular contraction or bodily movement by the actor.
- if bodily movement was controlled by mind of actor
acts = epileptic seizure, controlled by brain, but not by mind
Penal codes define possession as occurring if possessor knowingly procures item or fails to dispossess himself of it after made aware of its presence.
(1) voluntarily takes control
of item (voluntary act)
(2) receives item and was aware of his control of item for sufficient time to get rid of item.
(omission -- failure to meet duty to get rid of item)
A person is not guilty of crime for
failure to act even if failure permits harm to occur to another even if person
could've acted at no risk to self.
Unless there is a special duty to another
What are status relationships that require a duty to act?
Voluntary assumption of duty
What are the predicates to a duty to act.
-Must be aware of need to act or be
reckless or negligent regarding need to act.
-Must have the physical ability to
perform required duty
Felony Child Abuse
"knowingly exposing a child to a substantial risk of injury or neglect which does result in such injury."
Do strict liability offenses eliminate necessity for prosecution to prove a mens rea?
Common Law Transferred Intent
Person acts intentionally if result of conduct differs from that which she desired only with respect to identity of victim.
What are the 4 Mens Rea terms under the MPC
If element involves nature of conduct or result, must be
to engage in conduct of nature or to cause result
A person knowingly causes a result if she is aware the result is
to result from her conduct.
- Person acts recklessly if
consciously disregards substantial and unjustifiable risk
that the material element exists or will result from conduct
-Gross deviation from standard of conduct
of law-abiding person in actor's situation
- Conscious disregard Actor must be aware she is taking substantial and unjustifiable risk.
Person acts negligently when he should be aware of substantial and unjustifiable risk that the material element exists or will result from conduct.
- gross deviation from standard of care of
reasonable person in actor's situation
-Not aware of risk, but should be. Standard of reasonable person instead of law-abiding person
-In the MPC, If only one mens rea element is set out in definition of offense, mens rea term applies to every material element of offense, unless contrary legislative intent.
MPC defines crime of false imprisonment, as
: "knowingly restraining another so
as to interfere substantially with his liberty." material element = 1) restraining another, 2) substantially interfering with another's liberty.
Prosecutor must prove defendant knowingly restrained victim and knowingly interfered substantially with victim's liberty
What are the two types of battery
Offensive Touching Battery
Bodily Injury Battery
Common law definito of a voluntary cat
: a willed muscular contraction or bodily movement by the actor
If bodily movement was controlled by mind of actor.
What are some types of unwilled actions
Epileptic seizure: its controlled by
brain but not by mind
MPC example of non-voluntary acts
1) Reflex during convuilsion
2) Bodily movemment during unconsciousness or sleep
3) Conduct during hypnosis
Common law duty to act "commission by omission"
contractual obligation (express or implied)
Creation of risk
voluntary assistance <---- common law
-stop car at accident
-bad samaritan laws