neutral theories of molecular evolution T. 27 and species concepts T. 28 final exam.txt

Card Set Information

neutral theories of molecular evolution T. 27 and species concepts T. 28 final exam.txt
2011-12-11 12:02:18
species concepts theories molecular evolution

evol bio
Show Answers:

  1. Neutralist School
    • Wright, Kimura, Ohta, Gould
    • Most polymorphic alleles originate by neutral mutations and are maintained by
    • 1. genetic drift
    • 2. gene flow (rather than selection)
  2. Selectionist School
    • Darwin, A Russel Wallace, RA Fisher, HJ Muller
    • Most polymorphic alleles originate from Mutations w/some SELECTIVE value. These mutations w/favorable effects are MAINTAINED BY SELECTION, while those w/deleterious effects are LOST by selection
  3. Balanced School
    • JBS Haldene, Bruce Wallace, Theo. Dobzhansky, Kreitman, Dawkins
    • Most pholymorphic alleles originate from mutations w/Favorable selective effects (in time, place or genotype) are MAINTAINED by BALANCE of Completely SELECTIVE FORCES.
    • ie Sickle Cell Anemia: this can shorten lifespan of RBC to 90 days, but MALARIA parasite NOT able to survive, so there is genetically favored advantage to this
  4. Biological Species conept
    • Strongest Champion: Ernst Mayr
    • Species defined as: Groups of INTERBREEDING (intrinsic) natural population that are isolated from other groups.
    • Extrinsic - not able to interbreed & produce fertile offspring
    • Shortcomings: can't classify prok, can't classify ASEXUAL beings
  5. Phenotypic or Phylogenic Species concept
    • Strongest champion: Joel Cracraft. (dead are Aristotle, Darwin, Lamarck, Linneus, Fisher)
    • Phenogenic or Phylogenic clusters of organisms who share these traits based on ancestor-to-->descendent inheritance.
    • Species defined: Based on Phenotype, NOT offspring
    • Attempts to answer Product Question: why are we able to classify living organisms in a systematic and reproducible way
    • Shortcomings: NOT Objective
  6. Ecological or Evolutionary Species Concept
    • Strongest Champion: George Gaylord Simpson. (dead are Wright, Simpson, Leigh Van Valer, Wiley)
    • Species defined as: Lineage of organisms sharing SAME ADAPTIVE zone & evolutionary history
    • Answers persistance question: why species able to maintain themselves as stable recognizable groups over time
    • Shortcomings: may have something genetically distinct. Ie, cicadas have different lifecycles & NOT able to interbreed…arguing each are different species.