Court of general jurisdiction, can hear any sort of case
Constitutional due process
General jurisdiction - means you can sue on any claim regardless of whether the claim involves Connecticut
Specific jurisdiction -- Defendant is a non-resident who performed some act in CT AND claim is based on his activity in CT
General jurisdiction (constitutional due process)
You can sue on any claim regardless of whether the claim involves Connecticut.
Specific jurisdiction (constitutional due process)
Defendant is a non-resident who performed some act in CT
Claim is based on his activity in CT
Personal jurisdiction over individuals and partnerships
Presence - you serve them with process while in CT
Domicile - leads to general personal jurisdiction
Plaintiff's cause of action arises out of nonresident's Connecticut activity, such as:
Transaction of business in CT
Tortuous act in CT
Tortuous act outside the state causing injury within CT, AND defendant regularly does or solicits business, or derives substantial revenue from goods used or consumed or services rendered in CT; OR defendant expects or reasonably should expect tortuous act to have consequences in CT and derives substantial revenue from interstate or international commerce
Ownership, use, or possession of real property in CT
Personal jurisdiction over corporations
Incorporated in Connecticut
Foreign corporation licensed to do business in Connecticut
Foreign corporation transacting business in Connecticut without authorization (subject to suit on any cause of action arising out of such business)
Can a plaintiff have personal jurisdiction over a foreign corporation transacting business in Connecticut without authorization?
Yes, such corporations are subject to suit on any cause of action arising out of such unauthorized business in Connecticut.
Can parties consent to personal jurisdiction?
Yes, through contract forum selection clauses.
Forum Non Conveniens
Discretionary ground for dismissal. Defendant agrees court has jurisdiction but that the case would be better adjudicated elsewhere.
3) Events occured
What does proper service include?
Writ of summons
What must a writ of summons contain for proper service of process (and therefore proper notice)?
Signature by attorney for plaintiff as "commissioner of Superior Court," or by judge or clerk of court
Identification of parties
Specification of court
Direction to officer for service
How do you determine the return date?
Just a made-up date that other things are measured against
Service of process must be made at least 12 days before return date
Process must be filed with court at least 6 days before return date
Defendant must file appearance no later than 2 days after return date
When must service of process be made?
At least 12 days before return date.
When is the return date?
At least 12 days after service of process.
When must process be filed with the court?
At least 6 days before the return date.
When must the defendant file an appearance?
No later than 2 days after return date.
What are the constitutional due process limitations on the method of serving process?
Method must be reasonably calculated to give defendant fair notice of pendency of action so as to provide opportunity to be heard.
What is sufficient service of process to an individual?
In-person delivery, or
Someone at his usual place of abode
What is sufficient service of process to a partnership?
In-hand delivery to any member of the partnership.
How do you serve process out-of-state?
Use Connecticut method and out-of-state process server.
What is the "Secretary of State" option for service of process to an individual or partnership subject to long-arm jurisdiction?
Deliver one to CT Secretary of State
Mail second copy to defendant by registered or certified mail at defendant's out-of-state residence
What is sufficient service of process to a corporation?
In-hand delivery to officer, director, managing agent, or person in charge of office at principal place of business
CT corporation or foreign corporation authorized to transact business in CT -- can serve Secretary of State (optional)
Unauthorized foreign corporation over whom long-arm jurisdiction is available -- send by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, to corporation's principal office
Plaintiff or defendant reside in CT -- any judicial district in which either resides
All parties out of CT -- district where transaction or injury occured
Actions involving land -- district where land is located
Transfer of venue -- court will transfer to proper district either on motion or unilaterally
How do you determine venue when the plaintiff or the defendant residet in Connecticut?
Any judicial district in which either resides.
How do you determine venue where all parties reside outside of Connecticut?
District where the transaction or injury occured.
How do you determine venue in actions involving land?
District where the land is located.
How does the court transfer venue?
Court will transfer to proper district either on motion or unilaterally.
What is generally required of pleadings?
Signed by attorneys representing party
What is the proper order of pleadings?
Defendant's Motion to Dismiss
Defendant's Request to Revise the Complaint
Defendant's Motion to Strike the Complaint
Defendant's Answer to the Complaint
Plaintiff's Request to Revise the Defendant's Answer
Plaintiff's Motion to Strike the Defendant's Answer
Plaintiff's Reply to the Defendant's Answer
What is required of the plaintiff's complaint?
Must allege all relevant facts and all necessary elements of the cause of action.
Defendant's motion to dismiss
Lack of subject matter jurisdiction - a loser
No personal jurisdiction
Insufficient process - writ of summons was wrong
Improper service of process
Improper venue - instead of dismisisng will be transferred to venue that is appropriate
Can a defendant move to dismiss a case for improper venue?
Yes, but instead of dismissing, the case will be transferred to a venue that is appropriate.
Can a defendant request for the plaintiff to revise the complaint?
Yes, to clarify the allegations of the complaint or to delete scandalous or unnecessarily prejudicial allegations.
On what grounds can a defendant move to strike the complaint?
Legal insufficiency (failure to state a cause of action)
Failure to join a necessary party
What can a defendant include in its answer to the complaint?
Denials (joinder of issue)
Speical defenses -- defense that depends on facts not alleged by the plaintiff
Counterclaims against the plaintiff (needs service of process)
Cross-claims against co-defendants (needs service of process)
What is required in the plaintiff's reply to the defendant's answer?
As to special defenses: must file Reply denying allegations of special defense
Must file "Answer to Counterclaim"
NOTE: Failure to file either is considered an admission
What is the consequence of failure to follow chronological sequence of pleadings?
Failure to follow chronological sequence of pleadings constitutes waiver of right to file any pleading that was omitted in an earlier part of the response.
When must the defendant's first response be filed?
Within 30 days from the defendant's appearance.
Thereafter, each pleading is to be filed within 15 days from the prior filing unless a judicial ruling is necessary with respect to the prior filing.
When must a pleading be filed?
After the defendant's first response (which is due within 30 days from the defendant's appearance), each pleading is to be filed within 15 days from the prior filing unless a judicial ruling is necessary with respect to the prior filing.
What results from failure to plead?
Nonsuit or default.
Can there be multiple plaintiffs?
If the claim arises from the same transaction and occurrence and there is a common issue of law or fact.
Can there be multiple defendants?
If the defendants share an adverse interest toward plaintiff.
Person who shouldn't be a party hasn't been joined.
Substance - Defendant may implead, as a third-party defendant, any person who may be liable in whole or in part to defendant for damages defendant may have to pay plaintiff.
1) Motion by defendant
2) Exercuse of discretion by the court
3) Plaintiff may, within 20 days, assert a direct claim against the third-party defendant provided the claim airses out of the same transaction asserted by plaintiff in the main action
Who can the defendant implead as a third-party defendant?
Any person wh omay be liable in whole or in part to the defendant for damages the defendant may hve to pay the plaintiff.
What is the procedure for impleader?
Motion by defendant
Exercise of discretion by the court
Plaintiff may, within 20 days, assert a direct claim against the third-party defendant provided the claim airses out of the same trnasaction asserted by the plaintiff in the main action
What is the scope of discovery?
Any non-privileged information relevant to case and which might reasonably lead to evidence.
What discovery is available for testifying experts?
Other party may demand identity of experts intended to be called at trial as well as the substance of their opinions
Then depositions may be taken of the experts
Regardless of the presence of an interrogatory, each party, a reasonable time before trial, must disclose information about expert witnesses who will testify at trial
When must a party disclose information about expert witnesses who will testify at trial?
A reasonable time before trial, regardless of the presence of an interrogatory.
What discovery is avaiabile for nontestifying experts?
No disclosure is required of a mere consulting expert except upon showing of extraordinary circumstances.
What discovery devices can a party serve on the opposing party (but NOT on witnesses)?
Request for production of documents or things
Request for physical or mental examination
Request for admissions
Can you serve interrogatories, requests for production, requests for physical or mental examination, or request for admissions on witnesses?
No, these are discovery devices that you can only serve on the opposing party.
What notice is required to depose a party?
Serve notice on all parties to action.
What notice is required to depose a non-party?
Serve subpoena on non-party and give notice to all parties to action.
Can you demand production of documents by subpoena?
Yes, subpoena ducas tecum.
Subpoena ducas tecum
Used to demand production of documents.
When can you use depositions (in lieu of live testimony) for substantive uses?
Deponent is adverse party
Adverse party's officer, director, or managing agent or an employee who was designed by party to testify at deposition
Depondent is unavailable because of death, illness, out of state or otherwise unobtainable by subpoena
Depondent is located more than 30 miles from courthouse
Deponent is a health care provider
And you can ALWAYS use for contradiction and impeachment
What can you use deposition testimony for?
Substantive purposes (in lieu of live testimony under certain circumstances)