Schizophrenia Studies 2
Card Set Information
Schizophrenia Studies 2
What did Butzlaff and Hooley find?
Over 20 studies of expressed emotion were reviewed
70% of schizophrenics in such families relapsed within a year
30% of schizophrenics with families not displaying EE relapsed
What did Berger find?
Schizophrenics reported a higher level of double bind than non schizophrenics
What did Tienari find?
Adopted children in Finland with schizophrenic parents were more likely than a control group with non schizophrenic parents to become schizophrenics themselves
This difference only occurred when the adopted family was judged to be disturbed or dysfunctional
What did Liem find?
There was no difference in patterns of communication in families with a schizophrenic child and families without
What did Hall and Levin find?
In a review of family studies, no evidence of a contradiction in verbal and non verbal messages between children with schizophrenia and parents
What did Vaughn and Leff find?
EE plays an important part in schizophrenia relapse
The extent of emotional expression in families is a strong predictor of relapse rates amongst discharged patients
51% in high EE homes
13% in low EE homes
What did Szasz find?
Labelling someone as being mentally ill is nothing more than the medicalisation of madness
Using terms such as 'treatment' or 'illness' is a form of social control that robs the individual of their liberty
Labelling people is a way of excluding those who don't conform to social norms
What did Scheff find?
Schizophrenia is a learned social role determined by labelling
The label makes the person act in a way to fit it and changes the way others interpret their behaviour
Knowing somebody suffers from a psychiatric or psychological disorder creates a stigma
This creates feelings of social inadequacy in the person
What did Rosenhan find?
Once 'pseudo-patients' had been given the label of schizophrenics their subsequent behaviour was interpreted in a different way
What did Rosenhan find in his follow up study?
Rosenhan claimed that pseudo patients would attempt to gain entrance to a hospital that knew of his previous study over a 3 month period
Of the 193 admissions 41 were considered to be impostors
In reality, Rosenhan sent nobody
What did Spitzer find?
Staff at hospitals could not just turn away patients who turned up with symptoms, they have a duty of care
Most were given the label of 'schizophrenia in remission' which is rarely used and suggests that staff were unconvinced of their illness
What did Cole et al find?
P's took chlorpromazine for 6 weeks whilst a control group took sugar pills
0% got worse (48% in the control group)
5% showed no change (13% in CG)
18% showed some improvement (14% in CG)
75% showed much improvement (25% in CG)
What did Loebel find?
Not all patients respond to conventional drugs
16% failed to show any improvement within 12 months of the first treatment
What did Hill find?
30% of people taking anti psychotic drugs developed Tardive Dyskinasea
In 75% of cases, the condition is irreversible
What did Hogarty find?
: medication only
Group 2: medication and social skills training
Group 3: medication and family therapy
Group 4: medication, social skills training and family therapy
Group 1 relapse rate
Group 2 relapse rate
Group 3 relapse rate
Group 4 relapse rate
What did Hogarty find after his study?
Patients were followed up for a second year after family therapy and social training had ceased
Higher levels of relapse were observed
This suggests that therapy should continue, even when the patient is in the recovery phase
What did Doane et al find?
Treatments focussed on reducing EE in families reduced relapse rates
What did Goldstein and Falloon find?
Family therapy is very effective when combined with drugs