-
substantive assessment methods:
determining who among the minimally qualified will likely to be the best performers on the job
-
personality tests describe:
behavioral, not emotional or cognitive traits
-
Personality Tests: What are the Big Five Factors?
- 1. Emotional Stability
- 2. Extraversion
- 3. Openness to experience
- 4. Agreeableness
- 5. Conscientiousness
-
2 types of ability tests
- 1. Aptitude
- 2. Achievement
-
aptitude test assesses
innate capacity to function
-
achievement test assesses
learned capacity to function
-
4 classes of ability tests
- 1. Cognitive
- 2. Psychomotor
- 3. Physical
- 4. Sensory/perceptual
-
two types of job knowledge tests
- 1. assess knowledge of duties involved with the job.
- 2. level of experience with, and knowledge about, job tasks and tools necessary to perform the job
-
two types of integrity tests
- 1. clear purpose/over
- 2. personality-based/veiled purpose
-
Interest, values, and preference inventories assess
- -activities individuals prefer to do on and off the job; do not attempt to assess ability to do these
- -not often used in selection
- -can be useful for self-selection into job types
-
2 types of Structured Interviews
Situational and Experience (Behavioral)-based
-
Situational Interviews assess
applicant's ability to project his/her behaviors to future situations. Assumes the person's goals/intentions will predict future behavior.
-
Experience (Behavioral)-based Interviews assess
past behaviors that are linked to prospective job. Assumes pas performance will predict future performance.
-
Discretionary Assessment Methods are used to
separate people who receive job offers from list of finalists (assumes each finalist is considered fully qualified for position).
-
Contingent Assessment methods might involve confirmation of
- 1. drug test results
- 2. medical exam results
- 3. criminal background check
-
Internal selection: logic of prediction:
indicators of internal applicants' degree of success in past situations should be predictive of their likely success in new situations
-
Internal Selection: types of predictors
there is usually greater depth and relevance to the data available on internal candidates relative to external selection
-
5 Initial Assessment Methods
- 1. Skills inventory
- 2. Peer assessments
- 3. self-assessments
- 4. managerial sponsorship
- 5. Informal discussions and recommendations
-
Traditional Skills inventory containst
- -list of KSAOs held by each employee
- -records a small number of skills listed in generic categories, such as education, experience, and supervisory training received.
-
Customized Skills Inventory
- -specific skill sets are recorded for specific jobs
- -SMEs identify skills critical to job success
-
strengths of peer assessments
- -rely on raters who presumably are knowledgeable of applicants' KSAOs
- -peer more likely to view decisions as fair
-
weaknesses of peer assessments
- -may encourage friendship bias
- -criteria involved in assessments are not always clear
-
7 types of substantive assessment methods
- 1. seniority and experience
- 2. job knowledge tests
- 3. performance appraisal
- 4. promotability ratings
- 5. assessment centers
- 6. interview simulations
- 7. promotion panels and review boards
-
pros of hiring based on seniority and experience
- -direct experience in a job content area reflects an accumulated stock of KSAOs necessary to perform job
- - socially acceptable, viewed as rewarding loyalty
-
cons of hiring based on seniority and ecperience
- -seniority is unrelated to job performance
- -experience is moderately related to job performance
-
experience is superior to seniority because
it is a more valid method and is more likely to be content valid when past or present jobs are similar to the future job
-
Job knowledge tests includes elements of
both ability and seniority
-
Job knowledge tests are measured by
a paper and pencil test or a computer
-
Job knowledge tests hold great promise as a predictor of
job performance because they reflect an assessment of what was learned with experience and also capture cognitive ability
-
pros of performance appraisal as assessment method:
- -readily available info
- -probably capture both ability and motivation
-
cons of performance appraisal as assessment method:
- -potential lack of a direct correspondence between requirements of current job and requirements of position applied for
- -"peter" principle
-
promotability ratings are often conducted along with
performance appraisals
-
Assessment center objective
predict an individual's behavior and effectiveness in critical roles, usually managerial
-
assessment centers:
incorporate multiple methods of assessing multiple KSAOs using multiple assessors
-
validity of assessment centers is higher when
- -multiple predictors are used
- -assessors are psychologists rather than managers
- -peer evaluations are used
-
examples of Interview simulations
-role play, fact finding, or oral presentations
-
Promotion panels and review boards use:
multiple raters, which can improve reliability and can broaden commitment to decisions reached
-
Job knowledge, promotability ratings, and assessment centers are strong in terms of
reliability and validity
-
Interview simulations appear to be a promising technique for
public contact jobs
-
the purpose of discretionary assessment methods is to
narrow the list of finalists to those who will receive job offers
-
to add value, a predictor must:
add to prediction of success above and beyond forecasting powers of current predictors.
-
2 adverse impact issues
- 1. what if one predictor has high validity and high adverse impact?
- 2. what if another predictor has low validity and low adverse impact?
-
4 compensatory model types to determine assessment scores
- 1. Clinical prediction
- 2. Unit weighting
- 3. rational weighting
- 4. multiple regression
-
cut score:
separates applicants who advance from those who are rejected
-
Four consequences of cut scores
- 1. False Negative
- 2. True Negative
- 3. False Positive
- 4. True Positive
-
3 methods to determine cut scores
- 1. Minimum competency
- 2. Top-Down
- 3. Banding
-
Random selection
each finalist has equal chance of being selected
-
ranking
finalists are ordered from most to least desirable based on results of discretionary assessments
-
grouping
finalists are banded together into rank-ordered categories
-
decision makers: role of hr professionals
- -determine process used to design and manage selection system
- -contribute to outcomes based on initial assessment
- methods
- -provide input regarding who receives job offers
-
decision makers: role of managers
- -determine who is selected for employment
- -provide input regarding process issues
-
decision makers: role of employees
-provide input regarding selection procedures and who gets hired, especially in team approaches
-
3 requirements for enforceable contract:
- 1. offer
- 2. acceptance
- 3. consideration
-
disclaimers are
oral or written statements explicitly limiting an employee right and reserving that right for an employer
-
contingencies
extending a job offer contingent on certain conditions being fulfilled by offer receiver
-
Strategic Approach to Job Offers: Labor market conditions
be aware of supply availability or tightness
-
Strategic Approach to Job Offers: Organization needs
be aware of short- and long-term outcomes or cost control
-
Strategic Approach to Job Offers: applicant needs
be aware of reward sought or willingness to leave job
-
Strategic Approach to Job Offers: legal issues
be aware of contract language and/or EEO/AA goals
-
Job Offer Content:
- -Starting date
- -Duration of contract
- -Compensation
- -Hours
- -Special hiring inducements
- -Restrictions on employees
- -other terms/conditions
- -acceptance terms
-
Job offer process:
- -formulation of job offer
- - presentation of job offer
- -job offer acceptance and rejection
- -reneging
-
Formulation of Job Offer
- -knowledge of competitors
- -applicant truthfulness
- -likely reactions of offer receivers
- -policies on negotiations and initial offers
- -strategies for presenting initial offer
-
2 approaches to presentation of job offer
Mechanical and sales approach
-
the sales approach to the presentation of job offer:
offer must be developed and "sold" may include negotiation
-
2 types of turnover
voluntary and involuntary
-
Voluntary turnover: avoidable-could be prevented
- -try to prevent for high value employees
- -do not try to prevent for low value employees
-
-
3 Causes of Voluntary Turnover
- 1. Desirability of leaving (low job satisfaction etc)
- 2. Ease of Leaving (good labor market, low cost of leaving etc)
- 3. Alternatives (internal: new job possibilities; external: job offers)
-
turnover rate:
(number of employees leaving/ average number of employees) x 100
-
6 Guidelines for conducting exit interviews
- 1. Neutral Interviewer who has been trained to conduct exit interviews
- 2. Train-put employee at ease, follow format, end positively.
- 3. Format should contain questions about unavoidable and avoidable reasons for leaving
- 4. Interviewer should prepare by reviewing format and employee's personnel file
- 5. Interview should be private and before employee's last day.
- 6. Employee should be told that the interview is confidential.
-
Most effective retention initiatives
- 1. competitive merit increases/ salary adjustments
- 2. career development opportunities
- 3. promoting qualified employees
- 4. increasing health care benefits
- 5. flexible schedules
- 6. bonuses
-
5 step Progressive discipline system
- 1. give employees notice of rules of conduct and misconduct.
- 2. Give notice of consequences of violation of the rules
- 3. provide equal treatment for all employees
- 4. allow full investigation of alleged misconduct and defense by the employee
- 5. provide employees the right to appeal a decision
|
|